Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Oh no meat question
Low Carb Discussion Forum > The Livin' La Vida Low-Carb Plans > Who's On DANDR (Dr. Atkins' New Diet Revolution)?
lcmama
OKAy, Transitioning here from kk. I did have some previous low carb experience (Curves) a few years ago. My plan after reading some of Johnny Bowden's book was to go with DANDR
But with both of the previous Low carbs plans I tried before there was not so much of a call to eat the higher fat cuts of meat. I have just started reading DANDR but I have also been reading a lot of posts, mostly by Charles (thanks Charles) that kind of worries me.
I do not like the higher fat cuts of meat. I never have. once in a while I will eat prime rib if cooked very very well done and no fat on it, ground beef is really the only beef I enjoy and then the taste I prefer is of the 3-7% fat. I hate pork products, and although I love Turkey Bacon and Turkey sausage never really liked pork products. I love chicken, and turkey but hate the skin. I really only ENJOY the White meat of those although once ina while I will eat a skinless thigh. IS this whole way of eating not going to work for me? I would like to lose weight, AND get healthier but what I'm reading is scaring me. not for the same reason (Well okay a little) that others are afraid of the fat content, but because I won't stick with a woe that is mostly about foods I don't like.

Any input would be helpful here.
Thanks
Tria
Low Carb Discussion Forum
melodiegale
Icmama, Check out South Beach. They tend to recommend meats that are lower in fat. This plan might suite your palate more.
Jimmy Moore
I agree with Melodie...go back to Jonny's book and read about South Beach. He is more of a low-fat, low-glycemic diet rather than the high-fat (which you don't like!), low-carb diet of Atkins. It's all about finding the plan that works for you and then DOING IT! You can do this, my friend! Don't lose hope.
sjm
QUOTE (lcmama @ Sep 22 2007, 03:34 PM)
OKAy, Transitioning here from kk. I did have some previous low carb experience (Curves) a few years ago. My plan after reading some of Johnny Bowden's book was to go with DANDR
But with both of the previous Low carbs plans I tried before there was not so much of a call to eat the higher fat cuts of meat. I have just started reading DANDR but I have also been reading a lot of posts, mostly by Charles (thanks Charles) that kind of worries me.
I do not like the higher fat cuts of meat. I never have. once in a while I will eat prime rib if cooked very very well done and no fat on it, ground beef is really the only beef I enjoy and then the taste I prefer is of the 3-7% fat. I hate pork products, and although I love Turkey Bacon and Turkey sausage never really liked pork products. I love chicken, and turkey but hate the skin. I really only ENJOY the White meat of those although once ina while I will eat a skinless thigh. IS this whole way of eating not going to work for me? I would like to lose weight, AND get healthier but what I'm reading is scaring me. not for the same reason (Well okay a little) that others are afraid of the fat content, but because I won't stick with a woe that is mostly about foods I don't like.

Any input would be helpful here.
Thanks
Tria

There's no reason with Atkins why you have to eat the higher fat cuts of meat. What you need to do is to have lots of fat in your diet! Most of your calories will be coming from fat!!!

Fattier cuts of meat allow one to get more fat calories, but if you're willing to eat avocados, use mayonnaise, and olive oil, and the other ways of getting enough fat... you can still "do Atkins". Some people truly enjoy the fattier cuts... and Atkins allows that, but it's not "required".

Nor is eating pork required.

I think you should look at both Atkins and SB and see which one appeals to you... and which one would work better for your way of eating.

Just don't judge either plan on the most restrictive phase...


lcmama
Thanks, Melodie, Jimmy and SJM for your replies.

I am not giving up and actually I enjoy fat, just not meat fat. LOVE cheese, Avocado, Nuts, Peanut butter but I know I have to limit those. No problems with butter, mayo etc. I will check out South Beach too Just trying to get a plan down Really want to start by Monday. I have kind of been floundering a bit this week just trying to add more calories and more fat and some veggies after KK. Gained 5 but dropped two and 1/2 the next day and been holding steady there so not too bad for someone with no real plan in mind.

I appreciate your input and as always Jimmy... Thanks for the forum!
Tria
simons2cents
If it helps at all, I have been following Atkins for 2 years, and have managed to lose a significant amount of weight basing the majority of my meals around leaner cuts of meat, and lots of seafood. I do use butter, full fat salad dressings, cheese and other fats, but as far as the meat goes, most of mine is chicken breast and fish. Granted, most of my food is restaurant food, so it is probably prepared more "fatty" than the average home cook would do, but as long as you are aware of the need to use fats, I bet you will be fine with DANDR.
HalsAngel
Tria,
Sounds like you've got it going pretty well already, I'd like for you to go into the Journals and find my friend Ginger's.
She is doing alot better now since leaving KK and has learned to increase her fat & calorie counts too. Another thing Ya'll have in common~~she LOVES Peanut Butter.
She's a great gal & could help you blend in here also.

Good luck with your Jouney to your goal.
Su
valerieslivingbooks
Tria, there is no minimum fat requirement for Atkins, and there is no requirement to eat only certain cuts of meat in the Atkins book.

The requirement is that we not restrict fat; we should eat as much as tastes best to us.

There are definitely benefits to opening the door to fatty cuts of meat, imho, when it comes to making everything work together, especially when so many of us were/have been eating low-fat for years. Increasing dietary fat is important, and fatty cuts of meat are, for some of us, an easy way to do that.

But I am a *BIG* believer in trusting your own tastes and listening to your body on this WOE. If you feel nourished and satisfied and craving-free after your meals, and you're losing fat, then my guess is that you are doing something right. :-)

IMHO, the main thing is to take this Atkins warning very seriously:
"I cannot stress strongly enough that trying to do a low-fat version of Atkins will interfere with fat burning and derail your weight loss."

It certainly sounds like you have a good handle on that.

I think you are right on track when you hint that this WOE *must work for your tastes* in order to be sustainable. I absolutely agree.
Charles
QUOTE (lcmama @ Sep 22 2007, 04:34 PM)
meat. I have just started reading DANDR but I have also been reading a lot of posts, mostly by Charles (thanks Charles) that kind of worries me.

lcmama:

I'm very sorry that I confused you with my posts. You certainly don't have to do it "Charles' way." I was merely trying to show what is, in my view, the most effective way to lose on Atkins, as described in Chapter 7 of your DANDR, and my own experience with myself and many others in my personal life whom I help with this. That is, fatty protein as the foundation of your eating plan.

All of the other posters are quite correct that if you check out the Acceptable Foods List, you can find a wide variety of foods and if there are some that you like, you can use them and be very successful if you do the plan as written.

I didn't write it, I only try to apply its science in a way that is easy to do without all of the counting. I had great results and only want to share.

Please, find a plan, if not Atkins, that works for you and do it for life.

Welcome and best of luck,

Charles
karrie
Since mayo and butter are ok with you why not add these to you lean meats. Chicken with a mayo based dressing or steak and garlic butter are two ways I add fat.

karrie
simons2cents
Karrie, I had a burger the other day where they put garlic butter INSIDE the burger. Talk about GOOD! I had heard of people stufing cheese, and that, but the garlic butter was really over the top good. smile.gif
Bungee
Simon - that's sounds yummy! Adding that to this weeks lunch - a nice simply variation to a burger! biggrin.gif
TheOtherChristina
Si's burger reminds me that earlier in the summer DH had a butcher grind 2 lbs sirloin with 1 lb bacon for a special grilling treat ... How did the burgers turn out? Ohhhh my goodness! (This doesn't help lcmama ... sorry! I just followed the conversation.)
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
eXTReMe Tracker